I am familiar with the sign the OP mentioned. I think it's important to note that it is a sign that states what 10-15-20% tips would be based on tickets price. It in no way asks for tips that I recall. I have been on multiple Long Range trips where the captain will say straight out, "A standard tip is 15-25% of the ticket price, if we've provided good service."
Also, I have been on that boat many times, I'd be curious to know which deckhand said that. In all my trips with them I've never seen them refuse to gaff a fish. More importantly like others have said, I've had trips I spent a lot of money and made myself miserable by soles focusing on my "lack of success" and over the years learned to have many where I spend my money, take my chances and choose to have an enjoyable time regardless of what happens.
Quick story: I have a group of friends from LA I met many years ago while on a Red Rooster 3 day. In getting to know them on the way out, one started sharing that he had been on 9 trips where he didn't catch fish! Being impressed, I asked how he could keep showing up with a great attitude (which he had), and he simply said I am coming out to have a good time and get a break from life. I turned to him and said, I think you are going to have a trip of a lifetime right here. Sure enough, we caught 577 fish in two days. We've had many good trips since then, and some downright rough ones-but we've always had a good time. Hang in there, you'll have great trips and tuff ones- but you can always have a great time in nature once you decide to.
View attachment 1482483