Time for a YT regulation change?

Discussion in 'Fishing Chit Chat' started by the SLIDER, Jan 7, 2018.

  1. Azarkon

    Azarkon I've posted enough I should edit this section

    Location:
    California
    Name:
    Joe
    Boat:
    N/A
    • Messages:
      (1,667)
    • Likes Received:
      (1,271)
    I'll describe it in a different way - would you support a 20 fish limit for sand dabs? How about a 5 fish limit for rock fish? After all, both of these changes would be better for fish populations, so why don't we do it? Hell, why not lower total fish limits to 3? Who needs more than 3 fish a trip? Anyone who argues against this is just being greedy.

    When changes are not based on facts, anything can be justified.

    I support regulations that maximize opportunity for recreational fishermen, while being sustainable at the same time. Is keeping 4 to 5 pound yellowtail sustainable? In case it is, then it's not the government's business. People can decide for themselves whether such a fish is worth keeping, this is what having freedom is about, and it's surprising to me that so many people volunteer to give it up these days.
     
    Last edited: Jan 10, 2018
    Calvin Deshler and colemans224 like this.
  2. ?? fisherman

    ?? fisherman super Captain

    Location:
    Soul Cal
    Name:
    Mike
    Boat:
    Kencraft CC
    • Messages:
      (16,778)
    • Likes Received:
      (4,750)
    Haha...... I'm just looking for a simple yes or no answer dude LOL......... let's try this one more time....

    So you are good with people keeping 4-5lb yellowtail?

    No dodging politician answer this time..... just a YES or a NO ;)

    The unknown fisherman:p:
     
    plj46 and wils like this.
  3. Azarkon

    Azarkon I've posted enough I should edit this section

    Location:
    California
    Name:
    Joe
    Boat:
    N/A
    • Messages:
      (1,667)
    • Likes Received:
      (1,271)
    "It's not the government's business."

    Doesn't get easier than that.

    I might not support people's decision to keep baby yellowtail, but I'm going to support their right to do it. There are a lot of fishing practices that I don't like, but which are legal; and a lot of fishing practices that I do like, but which are illegal. In the end, the law should not depend on whether I personally like a fishing practice - it should be based on facts.
     
    26grumpy likes this.
  4. ?? fisherman

    ?? fisherman super Captain

    Location:
    Soul Cal
    Name:
    Mike
    Boat:
    Kencraft CC
    • Messages:
      (16,778)
    • Likes Received:
      (4,750)
    LOL LOL LOL

    It'll just kill ya to give a yes or no wouldn't it??

    To freakn' funny :D

    The unknown fisherman:p:
     
  5. Azarkon

    Azarkon I've posted enough I should edit this section

    Location:
    California
    Name:
    Joe
    Boat:
    N/A
    • Messages:
      (1,667)
    • Likes Received:
      (1,271)
    Because it's not a yes or no question, it's two questions in one.

    The first question is "are you okay with other people keeping 4 to 5 pound yellowtail"? The answer to this is YES, because it's legal and no data says it's not sustainable.

    The second question is "would you keep 4 to 5 pound yellowtail yourself?" The answer to this is generally NO, but I have kept them in the past when I badly wanted to bring home fish, so it could also be YES, depending on what I feel like on a given day.
     
  6. Azarkon

    Azarkon I've posted enough I should edit this section

    Location:
    California
    Name:
    Joe
    Boat:
    N/A
    • Messages:
      (1,667)
    • Likes Received:
      (1,271)
    I also don't think people appreciate the amount of meat that is on a 4 to 5 pound yellowtail. The largest rock fish I caught this year was just under 5 pounds, and a third of that was the head. A 4 to 5 pound yellowtail would give more meat than that 5 pound rock fish, and that 5 pound rock fish was probably 15 years old or more.

    Yeah, 4 to 5 pound fish is small by yellowtail terms. But with respect to meat value, it's a lot of meat. Equivalent to the limit of <1 pound rock fish that people often bring home in California. Would it be better to wait for the fish to become 30 pounds? Sure it would. But you could make that argument for any fish - they could always get bigger. The question with respect to utility is whether they're big enough, and with respect to conservation, whether the data says it's sustainable.
     
    Last edited: Jan 10, 2018
    Calvin Deshler likes this.
  7. mullet

    mullet Metal Fabricator

    Location:
    San Fernando Valley
    Name:
    Mike
    Boat:
    19"Gregor
    • Messages:
      (3,447)
    • Likes Received:
      (2,922)
  8. wils

    wils lazy-ass well known "member"

    Location:
    not a spoiled bitch from san diego
    Name:
    bill
    Boat:
    I hate boats
    • Messages:
      (8,672)
    • Likes Received:
      (4,579)
    :eek:.....:rofl:
     
    Yellowtail Dan, plj46 and hilltop like this.
  9. hilltop

    hilltop lurking in the shallows

    Location:
    sb 805
    Name:
    hilltop
    Boat:
    sold, pangas, Intrepid, and diggin the RRIII
    • Messages:
      (1,448)
    • Likes Received:
      (613)

    You'd think they would appreciate every tiny little bite from a 5lber............baby killers.
     
    Yellowtail Dan and wils like this.
  10. wils

    wils lazy-ass well known "member"

    Location:
    not a spoiled bitch from san diego
    Name:
    bill
    Boat:
    I hate boats
    • Messages:
      (8,672)
    • Likes Received:
      (4,579)
    then again.... it IS quite difficult to successfully release a GAFFED 5# yt.

    aw crap. there goes all that poundage of meat to the gaff damage........................
     
  11. wils

    wils lazy-ass well known "member"

    Location:
    not a spoiled bitch from san diego
    Name:
    bill
    Boat:
    I hate boats
    • Messages:
      (8,672)
    • Likes Received:
      (4,579)
    Yes. it is ok because the govt says its legal
    No. it is NOT ok because we don't like govt regulations and the govt says that its legal.

    Gosh but I love postings that appear on BD during Happy Hour

    govt regulations TRUMP in our society.
     
  12. ShadowX

    ShadowX I've posted enough I should edit this section

    Location:
    Los Angeles
    Name:
    Alex
    Boat:
    None
    • Messages:
      (1,314)
    • Likes Received:
      (672)
    Its not a scare storm. Yellowtail has always been a bonus if caught. Nobody stop fishing when the count for yellowtail is zero on the cattle boats. You have no facts that say the sportfishing fleet will be decimated by a size restriction on yellowtail.

    Nobody is saying that yellowtails will become extinct. I am merely saying that by putting in a restriction on SIZE, it would allow a better CHANCE of a local population that stays around. That is not unreasonable. On the other hand, you have no lower size limit, it decimates the population every time they come back north when the water gets warmer.

    Your comparison to the rockfish closure is not the same. That is an outright ban on fishing rockfish during certain time of the season. The yellowtail restriction is only on the minimum size. I would wager to bet the ban also helps give the rockfish a chance during spawning season. I have been noticing a lot more smaller reds and other rockfish ever since the ban has been in place. It means there is a chance of having a more sustainable resource in the long run. Nobody in the sportfishing business benefits from a species becoming scarce.

    I would argue that having more yellowtail caught throughout the year would benefit sportfishing more than just to catch them during El Nino years and have them disappear entirely for 7-8 years until the next cycle.
     
    charger98, wils and plj46 like this.
  13. Yellowtail Dan

    Yellowtail Dan I've posted enough I should edit this section

    Location:
    Roseville Ca
    Name:
    Dan
    Boat:
    Excel, American Angler
    • Messages:
      (2,143)
    • Likes Received:
      (1,402)
    Yep.....nailed it they’re loaded.....
     
  14. ShadowX

    ShadowX I've posted enough I should edit this section

    Location:
    Los Angeles
    Name:
    Alex
    Boat:
    None
    • Messages:
      (1,314)
    • Likes Received:
      (672)
    Are you serious? If you can bounce a yellowtail, it needs to go back into the water. They grow very fast and a 5 lb yellowtail is a baby. It may not even be one year old yet. Rockfish is not even in the same league since they grow at a much slower pace. Stop comparing the two. If I caught a 5 lb rockfish, I would release it back into the wild to spawn again. The same applies to large sheephead.

    Let's put it this way, if you are too embarrassed to post picture of the YT you caught, its too small. Some of the YT caught on the cattle boat and kept are smaller than the bonitos.
     
    Last edited: Jan 10, 2018
    charger98 and plj46 like this.
  15. Willdoggy

    Willdoggy Willing Member

    Location:
    Chula Vista
    Name:
    IG = WetWillyBiz
    Boat:
    Purr-Sea-Stance: Boston Whaler Montauk 170
    • Messages:
      (2,012)
    • Likes Received:
      (2,418)
    And some of the Bonito caught have been as large or larger than Yellowtail this year on private boats.
    Let’s ban fishing for them too!! But first I want to ban Fishing for Yellowtail Tuna! They are extremely elusive and very pesky critters.

    41BF288D-0ADC-40BB-9D7F-FC1008AD0CCA.jpeg
     
    Hardcor and colemans224 like this.
  16. fishkilr

    fishkilr on the water

    Location:
    long beach,ca.u.s.a.
    Name:
    alby
    Boat:
    Indian/Aahi/Inseine
    • Messages:
      (2,545)
    • Likes Received:
      (2,921)
    Since you say over and over there is a lack of data on yellows shouldn't such a situation be treated carefully to protect such a regal fish...
    What you don't seem to get is that yellows are a top of the list fish for many guys that fish often... it is my personal favorite and seeing limits of dead peanut yellows killed before they got the opportunity to become that freight training structure seeking missile that we get the pleasure to battle makes a lot of guys sick...
    This species holds a special place in the hearts of many experienced guys and they will defend it regardless of data ..
     
    Last edited: Jan 10, 2018
    plj46, charger98, jer dog and 2 others like this.
  17. No Cal Lou

    No Cal Lou No Cal Lou

    Location:
    Green Valley, Az
    Name:
    Lou Salatich
    Boat:
    none
    • Messages:
      (1,569)
    • Likes Received:
      (799)
    I think there should also be a size limit on Yellow Fin tuna. Say 15 pounds. As for limits 10 fish over 15#.
     
  18. jer dog

    jer dog Fishing is life

    Location:
    Garden Grove
    Name:
    Gerry
    Boat:
    One that floats
    • Messages:
      (6,830)
    • Likes Received:
      (3,206)
    the biggest think these days , if some one goes Fishing
    and it Cost them $145.00 for a 3/4 Day Trip
    They want too Bring Home a $145.00 worth of Fish
    plan and Simply
    when you Get Older, it Doesn't Matter How Much
    you Spend on a Trip, because you love just being out their
    and if you Catch Something it a Bonus.
    no matter how much the Trip Cost.
     
    Exodus likes this.
  19. colemans224

    colemans224 Member

    Location:
    SoCal
    Name:
    Tim
    Boat:
    seaswirl cc
    • Messages:
      (566)
    • Likes Received:
      (248)
    Is this a serious question?

    Hell yeah i’d Kill a few 4-5 lbers. Less competition for the surviving yellows and less sea lion food.
     
    Last edited: Jan 12, 2018
  20. Willdoggy

    Willdoggy Willing Member

    Location:
    Chula Vista
    Name:
    IG = WetWillyBiz
    Boat:
    Purr-Sea-Stance: Boston Whaler Montauk 170
    • Messages:
      (2,012)
    • Likes Received:
      (2,418)
    I wouldn't keep them but I would also not vote for or foster a law that prevents them from choosing to. Isn't it more fun anyway to shame them into releasing fish this size next time? Free country is better kept free.
     
    Last edited by a moderator: Jan 11, 2018
    26grumpy and Hardcor like this.

Share This Page