The last trip I was on (17 day) I gave the most money to the crew, like $3500. However, a person is not a scumbag because he doesn’t give tip money to someone. I have never received tip money in my 45 years of working and I personally believe that a customer should not have to supplement the wages that a owner of a business denies his workers. If the workers are choosing to work at a place with low wages, that is their problem. Now, honesty is a different issue, not paying for drinks or stealing tackle is a bad omen, I had customize a few bluefin jigs that would retail for $125 and some angler stole one off my rod and the other hanging off my box. Good luck trying to catch fish with stolen gear.
Why not sell trips that includes gratuity?
I have been fishing long range for 35 years and have had experienced many trips with terrible crew members, most are hard working, some are not. Many are helpful, others are worthless. Look at the Schedules for Long Range trips. You see some boats canceling multiple trips, why is that? Other boats are leaving the same time and length , fishing the same areas and are waiting list only. There are some boats I will not fish (and you know the names) because IMO the operation sucks and they really do not know how to find fish. Other boats the operation thinks they are doing you a big favor by letting you fish on their boat. One thing recessions do accomplish is to put people out of business that do not take care of their customers.