That's a tough call there . Sounds like you need a hard cooler for your catch.Interested in the reviews of the kill bag also! Drips are not an option since the wife would kill me if we got funky smelling fish juice in the car.
Because of the name, I am a hardcore PELAGIC fan. I have noticed all of their products ,have lower quality, every year.All of the bags I've used have leaked. Reliable being the best with the pleated seam on the bottom to make the bag wider. Get the size bigger than you think you need. The small ones don't hold a ton of fish once you add ice.
By far the Pelagic bags were the worst, don't buy one! Zippers blow out and the webbing tears.
What size are you guys buying? Wanna make sure I'm not getting something too small and at the same time too big it won't fit in my FJ.