February 28, 2011 Lahaina Harbor, Maui

Tues

Not my job...
Mar 17, 2008
6,193
43
48
Saluki
Name
Likes
Boat
Penis
So guys on 16 day trips coming home with 20, 150lb+ tuna with 12 wahoo..is OK? Do you know how much fish that is?

To each their own. Why does everyone worry about everyone else? Fuck me!
 

5150

Member
Aug 4, 2004
747
28
28
59
California
Name
JB
Boat
Matson Inc.
If the fishery in Hi is hot and cold, and they either eat fish or tofu depending on what they catch, is this because, just maybe, it's over fished?
 

grander007

Well-Known "Member"
May 10, 2007
1,762
122
63
Honolulu
Name
zzzz
Boat
46, Bertram, Deep Blue
According to all the big government reports that you CA guys love, HI has the same marlin catch rate per angler day as the rest of the US. It is not overfished, and certainly not by charter boats. If you all are so passionate about not killing fish, I suggest you spend your valuable time on another forum. We are fine here on our own w/ our gaffs and bang sticks.

That's it,
 
Jan 26, 2009
48
0
0
CA
Name
the_reel_deal
Boat
too many to list
So if this is true then we really do not need to worry about the decimation of the species in the sea of Cortez
that is a plus. But thats just me.
If you couldn't sell your 5lb. fish wouldn't you take it home and share it with your Just my opinion, eat fish have a great time on the water and make some $
While you might have done well on your high school debating team w/ this kind of thoughtfulness, the simple fact remains that charter boats in HI or for that matter anywhere never were and are not decimating the fish population. Do you want them to put up all the pictures of when they are skunked? Really, you need to find another tree to piss on, or hug.

Over and out.
 
Last edited:

Morris Lures

Pirate
Feb 17, 2010
711
108
43
Mililani, Hawaii
Name
Nick
Boat
FORCE 21
Those fish are small and should have been put back. Happy customers? Who cares. People who never fish took hand offs on 5# dorado and winched it in on on 80 pound gear I bet. This is not fishing.

So the marlin over there stay small, the dorado apparently stay small, but the Skipjack get fucking huge? Makes perfect sense.

<iframe style="border: 2px inset ; width: 100%; height: 100px;" tabindex="1" id="vB_Editor_QR_iframe"></iframe>
Makes perfect sense ur uneducated and an idiot. Marlin stay small I don't think so we have more giant Marlin here compared to lots of places. Mahimahi are the fastest growing pelagic fish in the ocean and they breed like rabbits. Skipjack get huge, ur a idiot people love skipjack over here just as much as any other fish. So if ur trying to imply they get huge cause we throw them back ur definitely in left field.

If the fishery in Hi is hot and cold, and they either eat fish or tofu depending on what they catch, is this because, just maybe, it's over fished?
Yeah it is over fished by all the longline boats. You bitch about a couple small fish. If u ever went to the auction in Hawaii and seen all the fish these guys rape u would definitely change ur opinion about a couple guys catch some small mahi for dinner or to make their charter happy. If u ever go to the auction walk to the back and check out the dumpster loads of mahi and other fish they trash cause they been sitting on the boat for way to long.
 

Indulgence

Newbie
May 17, 2003
62
0
0
52
commoniwannalayya
Visit site
Name
Joe
Boat
NONE!!!
Makes perfect sense ur uneducated and an idiot. Marlin stay small I don't think so we have more giant Marlin here compared to lots of places. Mahimahi are the fastest growing pelagic fish in the ocean and they breed like rabbits. Skipjack get huge, ur a idiot people love skipjack over here just as much as any other fish. So if ur trying to imply they get huge cause we throw them back ur definitely in left field.



Yeah it is over fished by all the longline boats. You bitch about a couple small fish. If u ever went to the auction in Hawaii and seen all the fish these guys rape u would definitely change ur opinion about a couple guys catch some small mahi for dinner or to make their charter happy. If u ever go to the auction walk to the back and check out the dumpster loads of mahi and other fish they trash cause they been sitting on the boat for way to long.
Please... it's not about small mahi's or tuna...they grow quickly. Most of us were unhappy to see stripe marlin that weighted less than 100lbs hanging from the rack. Thats all and YES i totaly agree with all of the posts that comment on long liners..they decimate all the pelagic species. Same goes for drift nets!
 
Nov 9, 2005
1,321
14
38
U.S.
Name
Jeff
Boat
"NAU-SEA"
NOW YOUR TALKING!

But it sure is sad you had to kill that poor wonderfull fish that was so innocent and just trying to get a bite to eat:rofl::rofl::rofl::rofl::rofl::rofl::rofl::rofl:!


-J
 

Corndog

Landlocked
Sep 22, 2009
4,860
1,601
113
Northern Colorado
Name
Jason Jones ( Lone Shark)
Boat
Century 1801, Hobie PA14 & SoA
Please... it's not about small mahi's or tuna...they grow quickly. Most of us were unhappy to see stripe marlin that weighted less than 100lbs hanging from the rack. Thats all and YES i totaly agree with all of the posts that comment on long liners..they decimate all the pelagic species. Same goes for drift nets!
x2...Thats kinda what I was implying in my post on page 3...Ill admit ive killed a rat dodo/mahi before and Ive certainly bbq'd some 7lb yellowfin before...mass production fast growing species...just seein a 50lb striper hanging upside down was the only thing that really raised my eyebrows...hey if thats how they do it then thats how they do it...Its just too bad everytime this conversation comes up it goes to blows without any real CONVERSATION going on...just name calling...I would love to visit Hawaii some day...Beautiful place for sure...But if I went on a Billfishing trip I think I would check into panama LOL.

tight lines~
 

dweston

Well-Known "Member"
May 12, 2008
2,844
219
63
vista Ca. USA
Name
Duane
Boat
yours
So guys on 16 day trips coming home with 20, 150lb+ tuna with 12 wahoo..is OK? Do you know how much fish that is?

To each their own. Why does everyone worry about everyone else? Fuck me!
Keep as much as you want who cares.

While you might have done well on your high school debating team w/ this kind of thoughtfulness, the simple fact remains that charter boats in HI or for that matter anywhere never were and are not decimating the fish population. Do you want them to put up all the pictures of when they are skunked? Really, you need to find another tree to piss on, or hug.

Over and out.
I do not know how my post got mixed with Jason's but in no way am I implying that CHARTER boats will or ever decimate a fish population. Hey if posting pics of small fish do it for you than go a head. I think you are missing my point this is a Charter Sportfishing operation and they are using this forum for advertising purposes.
Well this is a first for me being called a tree hugger:rofl:, but if practicing catch and release and believing in CONSERVATIONISM means I am a tree hugger than guilty as charged. :finger:
 

dweston

Well-Known "Member"
May 12, 2008
2,844
219
63
vista Ca. USA
Name
Duane
Boat
yours
Makes perfect sense ur uneducated and an idiot. Marlin stay small I don't think so we have more giant Marlin here compared to lots of places. Mahimahi are the fastest growing pelagic fish in the ocean and they breed like rabbits. Skipjack get huge, ur a idiot people love skipjack over here just as much as any other fish. So if ur trying to imply they get huge cause we throw them back ur definitely in left field.



Yeah it is over fished by all the longline boats. You bitch about a couple small fish. If u ever went to the auction in Hawaii and seen all the fish these guys rape u would definitely change ur opinion about a couple guys catch some small mahi for dinner or to make their charter happy. If u ever go to the auction walk to the back and check out the dumpster loads of mahi and other fish they trash cause they been sitting on the boat for way to long.
If this is really true then why do so many people post on here how nothing goes to waste?
 

bajadog

Running around knees bent
May 13, 2005
612
34
28
San Diego
Name
Name
Boat
Yours
Ever heard of releasing billfish? That's been happening in Latin America for years.
 

randay

Newbie
Nov 11, 2010
60
34
18
hawaii
Name
randay
Boat
17.5 glasply
Aloha from Lahaina Harbor. The billfish bite off the leeward side of Maui is extremely hot. Striped marlin have been attacking lures in packs and some anglers have been returning to the harbor with double digit counts of marlin bites. In addition to the striped marlin, some shortbill spearfish and nice blue marlin have been around. There has also been the usual steady trickle of mahis and tunas coming into the harbor. Overall, the fishing is great right now. For more information on the fishing, call Deli at 808-667-7879 between 9 a.m. and 5 p.m. Hawaii time or email [email protected]. The pictures below contain our anglers and some of their catch from the past week.

The ocean erupted behind the short corner lure just south of the Lanai lighthouse in 100 fathoms. This blue marlin would not give up on the purple softhead and finally, after six attempts, the fish managed to eat the lure. The hook-up was solid and 18 year old Steve Stupak from Deluth, Minnesota was tight with a monster. The fight was tough, lasting an hour and ten minutes, but Steve did a great job and the marlin ended up on the boat. The official weight for the blue marlin was 649.7 lbs. so, in accordance with Start Me Up’s policy for marlin over 500 lbs., Steve’s trip was free and a 300 dollar donation was made to a local charity. Congratulations to Steve on catching the fish of a lifetime.

Roger Stern had a very interesting fishing trip. He was able to enjoy the thrill of catching this mahi and was also fortunate enough to witness what he called an epic battle between Steve and the blue marlin.

There were striped marlin all around for Amanda and Mark Quam and Ann and Matt Sutton. They successfully caught and released two near the Lanai lighthouse and picked up two mahis as well. With all that action, these anglers described their morning as awesome.

Mike and his twin boys Nick and Alec trolled the 100 fathom ledge and got a couple of bites. They converted on both bites, landing these two mahis.

There was chaos all around the boat as striped marlin appeared to be everywhere. After all of the action, which featured triple bites, Clint Berg had a striped marlin with enough fillets to feed everyone on the boat.

Shantel Williams landed this mahi on a short morning trip. That’s not a bad way to spend a morning.

The Adams family also went out in the morning and caught a striped marlin. The marlin was caught while trolling the inside pinnacle known as secret spot on a black Jr. Popsicle.

The proud father and son team of Manning and Connor Louie came up with this mahi on a short morning trip. They will certainly have fond memories of their fishing experience.

These lucky anglers returned late in the evening from an afternoon trip. They took advantage of the afternoon bite to catch a mahi in addition to a nice shortbill spearfish.

Tom Carroll, Jim Lawrence, Rich Roman, and Mike Dennison were able to bring some good seafood back to the harbor. They caught a couple of shibis and a mahi.

Roger Paye and his wife Cindy caught and released a striped marlin and boated a 28 lb. aku. That is a big aku, or skipjack tuna, which are actually called otaru when exceeding weights of 20 lbs. Michael O’Brien also got lucky and caught and released a striped marlin. This group had a great day on the water.

Ben Rock, from West Virginia, was rock solid when he reeled in this mahi. Ben came across his mahi while trolling the 100 fathom ledge off Lanai.

Nathan Millar did a four hour afternoon trip and hooked up to a striped marlin in the vicinity of LA buoy. Nathan caught the fish, which was released, and said that he had a great time on his first fishing trip in Hawaii.

Jim Higgins also caught a fish on his first fishing trip in Hawaii. Jim boated this mahi while trolling near the Lanai lighthouse.

Greg Garritsen and Mike Fry each caught a striped marlin. Both marlin were caught in the area between sweetheart rock and the lighthouse on Lanai.

Jace McNaic and Caroline and Mitch Bartrem didn’t need a very long time to find the fish. They were on their way in from LA buoy on a two hour trip when these fish bit. Working together, Jace, Caroline, and Mitch brought the mahis to the boat.

NASA buoy was holding some fish and Craig Similik and Mike Paraclowski made the most of their opportunity. Craig caught a striped marlin and Mike caught several tunas. They also caught a mahi to end up with a mixed bag of fish.

Johannes McDonald, all the way from South Africa, landed a nice cow mahi and Doug Hansen and his wife caught a fish for the dinner table. They all said that they had a fun day.

With a total of ten marlin bites, Shaun Sutton and Gary Coleman were each able to catch and release a striped marlin. All of their action came while trolling on the backside of Lanai.

In this case, the picture does not tell the entire story of the trip. Although Sheldon and Melanie Burch and Dean and Debra Scammell did get a mahi on the boat, they missed eight marlin. Most were striped marlin but one was a nice blue marlin. All of the action took place behind Lanai. This trip is just another example of how tough billfishing can be.

Gwen Miller, George Russell, and Rosanne and Gene Schmaltz did an afternoon trip and fished relatively shallow water along the inside ledge. The ledge produced these two mahis and there were plenty of whales to be seen.

There was mayhem on the back deck when four striped marlin charged through the spread. Stephanie Carpenter took advantage of the quadruple bite to land her first ever ocean fish.

Even with all the billfish around, Jason Chisholm was still happy to catch this nice mahi.

Maui Fishin lures, made by Captain Steve Carroll, are always on display in Start Me Up’s booth at Lahaina Harbor. Captain Steve designs and produces these baits, all of which have been productive. The large lure has caught numerous marlin. Captain Steve is partial to the marlin lure in black and red although the so-called Coors Light colors have also been used with great success. The smaller flat-head lure also works great. The lure is not very big, but makes a lot of noise in the spread. Captain Steve’s small bullet lure, though, is a favorite among quite a few captains, especially in the color blue. The small bullet is a favorite because of the proven ability to catch all types of fish time and time again.

This is one of Captain Steve’s larger marlin lures. With Start Me Up Sportfishing embedded in the head, some anglers take these lures home as souvenirs. Some of the anglers actually choose to use the lures back at home. One angler, for example, intended to use a Maui Fishin lure to target walleye in Canada. Anglers could also opt to use Maui Fishin lures while fishing on Maui, where the lures are known to work well.

This is the Maui Fishin small bullet lure. Pink has been another one of the very productive colors, but the shape of the lure head itself is so good that the fish probably don’t even care about color.

Thanks for checking out yet another Start Me Up fishing report. If anyone would like a daily report for Lahaina Harbor, call our booth at 808-667-7879 between 9 a.m. and 5 p.m. Hawaii time or email [email protected]. Our next report will probably be posted within a week. Until then, tight lines.

Aloha,
Jonny
Jonny, great job! after six tries you guys finally got that marlin on the line for Steve, thats pretty incredible. My first marlin was only 91 pounds, not much. 650 pounds... im sure he'll still be telling that story when hes 80. And thanks for tagging and releasing those 6 striped marlin. Im sure some billfish conservationists will really appreciate that! Keep up the good work!
 

Capt. G

BD Outdoors Contributor
May 25, 2007
11,128
13
0
Osaka, Japan
www.bigbait.jp
Name
Capt. G
Boat
黒潮No.2
If we just closed all areas to all types of fishing, we would not have to bicker about keeping legally caught fish.
I think there are some people in Cali that can help up with shutting down fishing....
 

dweston

Well-Known "Member"
May 12, 2008
2,844
219
63
vista Ca. USA
Name
Duane
Boat
yours
If we just closed all areas to all types of fishing, we would not have to bicker about keeping legally caught fish.
I think there are some people in Cali that can help up with shutting down fishing....
Where did you ever come up with closing areas to fishing? I love all the Cali bashing WTF? I am done with this thread.:rofl:
 

Startmeup

Official Sponsor of Bloodydecks
Advertiser
Dec 9, 2008
698
11
18
Lahaina, Hawaii, USA
www.sportfishingmaui.com
Name
Lee
Boat
Start Me Up Sportfishing
Start Me Up is in business to try and earn a living for 27 captains, deckhands, office personnel, and maintenance people. In addition, we contribute to many other fishing related companies and other businesses, helping to keep our economy going. The profit probability is so low that it is a good thing we and our crew love fishing and boating.


Start Me Up’s fish policy is to tag and release or take marlin as our paying customers decide! We talk to our customers about tag and release and why it is a good practice. If marlin come up dead or mortally wounded we do not throw them back to be wasted similar to how the long-line marlin catch is discarded dead. If we take a marlin it is used as food and served in many ways. Even the fish carcasses are used in gardens and homes. People come by our booth daily to take the remains of our fish. Hawaii was one of the first cultures to practice conservation. Fishermen in Hawaii are proud to catch and eat the fish we have in these waters.

<?xml:namespace prefix = o ns = "urn:schemas-microsoft-com<img src=" /><o:p></o:p>
Start Me Up has customers of all ages, all colors, and from all walks of life. Many of these people only get to fish once in their life. Whether they catch or not, we try to provide a fun and informative day to all. For the most part, we feel our customers become our friends (and Bloodydecks readers) and continue to follow us through our Bloodydecks posts. Some of them become involved in the Bloodydecks forum in the area where they live. A small mahi or tuna can represent the only catch of the day. That catch can also represent the only fish these people will ever catch. A small one tastes just as good as a big one and if in fact it is sold to a restaurant that is yet another chance for people from all over the world to enjoy fresh Pacific Ocean caught fish.

<o:p></o:p>
Mahi, tuna, ono, and marlin are not endangered in any way by rod and reel fishermen. The longline fisheries regularly discard marlin, mahi, and ono to make room for the targeted tuna. This is who the criticism of rod and reel fishermen should be focused on. Change the way they catch their fish so they can release live fish that are not desired.

<o:p></o:p>
As the owner of Start Me Up I am proud of the fine people surrounding me in this tough business. I am also proud of the sacrifices they make to do what they love. We as a company are proud to be a part of the Hawaiian fishery. It makes us happy to share our catch and stories with local sportfishermen here on Bloodydecks and the world of other fishermen reading our posts.
<o:p></o:p>
Thanks for your support in reading our posts. Most of all, thanks to all the others that take the time and effort to share their great catches, good days, and bad days here on Bloodydecks. In closing, I hope all of you get the kind of enjoyment you want from the great opportunity we have for fun, food, comradery, pleasure, and learning that we call fishing.
<o:p></o:p>

If you have any concerns, call me on my personal cell phone at 808-960-3662.
<o:p></o:p>

Doug Armfield
 

grander007

Well-Known "Member"
May 10, 2007
1,762
122
63
Honolulu
Name
zzzz
Boat
46, Bertram, Deep Blue
That is very well said! Thanks for your support of BD as well, which gives us a place to share fishing stories and pictures,

Tight lines,
 

dweston

Well-Known "Member"
May 12, 2008
2,844
219
63
vista Ca. USA
Name
Duane
Boat
yours
Start Me Up is in business to try and earn a living for 27 captains, deckhands, office personnel, and maintenance people. In addition, we contribute to many other fishing related companies and other businesses, helping to keep our economy going. The profit probability is so low that it is a good thing we and our crew love fishing and boating.


Start Me Up’s fish policy is to tag and release or take marlin as our paying customers decide! We talk to our customers about tag and release and why it is a good practice. If marlin come up dead or mortally wounded we do not throw them back to be wasted similar to how the long-line marlin catch is discarded dead. If we take a marlin it is used as food and served in many ways. Even the fish carcasses are used in gardens and homes. People come by our booth daily to take the remains of our fish. Hawaii was one of the first cultures to practice conservation. Fishermen in Hawaii are proud to catch and eat the fish we have in these waters.

<?xml:namespace prefix = o ns = "urn:schemas-microsoft-com<img src=" /><o:p></o:p>
Start Me Up has customers of all ages, all colors, and from all walks of life. Many of these people only get to fish once in their life. Whether they catch or not, we try to provide a fun and informative day to all. For the most part, we feel our customers become our friends (and Bloodydecks readers) and continue to follow us through our Bloodydecks posts. Some of them become involved in the Bloodydecks forum in the area where they live. A small mahi or tuna can represent the only catch of the day. That catch can also represent the only fish these people will ever catch. A small one tastes just as good as a big one and if in fact it is sold to a restaurant that is yet another chance for people from all over the world to enjoy fresh Pacific Ocean caught fish.

<o:p></o:p>
Mahi, tuna, ono, and marlin are not endangered in any way by rod and reel fishermen. The longline fisheries regularly discard marlin, mahi, and ono to make room for the targeted tuna. This is who the criticism of rod and reel fishermen should be focused on. Change the way they catch their fish so they can release live fish that are not desired.

<o:p></o:p>
As the owner of Start Me Up I am proud of the fine people surrounding me in this tough business. I am also proud of the sacrifices they make to do what they love. We as a company are proud to be a part of the Hawaiian fishery. It makes us happy to share our catch and stories with local sportfishermen here on Bloodydecks and the world of other fishermen reading our posts.
<o:p></o:p>
Thanks for your support in reading our posts. Most of all, thanks to all the others that take the time and effort to share their great catches, good days, and bad days here on Bloodydecks. In closing, I hope all of you get the kind of enjoyment you want from the great opportunity we have for fun, food, comradery, pleasure, and learning that we call fishing.
<o:p></o:p>

If you have any concerns, call me on my personal cell phone at 808-960-3662.
<o:p></o:p>

Doug Armfield
Great post and thank you for clarifying your companies position. You sir are a true professional.
 

Morris Lures

Pirate
Feb 17, 2010
711
108
43
Mililani, Hawaii
Name
Nick
Boat
FORCE 21
Now lets all get back to fishing and filling BD with fish reports. Safe fishing and tight lines everyone.