Offshore Excalibur 1.5 day 7/18 - 7/20

WmWiley

Newbie
May 21, 2021
22
113
60
Point Loma
Name
Steven Vogt
Boat Name
CynSea
Long time reader, first time poster. Go easy. I'll be brief.

First time on the Excalibur. Pros and Cons:

Pros:
1. The crew. Ryan and Alex on deck, Jr. was training (his first day and he was very good. Helpful, a small guy, so agile on deck. Always asking if he can tie a knot or undo a tangle.) All three were good at helping and seeing problems before they happen. Omar was the chef and made some decent meals.
2. Older wooden boat, so smooth ride and good sleep. Creaked like a muthah, though.
3. Huge bunks. Mostly, if not all, doubles. Very wide, very long. Several staterooms as well. I had a stateroom and appreciated the extra large bunk size.
4. Good fishing platform...lot's of room to negotiate during open bites.
5. Capt. Chuck Taft. Salty and put us on fish.


Cons:
1. Old wooden boat, so you're not going anywhere fast.
2. No place sit on deck, which is pretty common, so bring a chair if you want to sit.
3. Lot's of freeboard at the bow, but spacious enough to comfortably throw irons, not so good for flylining.
4. Our stateroom blew hot air out of the a/c registers. That sucked.
5. $30 fuel surcharge, but that's expected.
6. Capt. Chuck Taft...salty...real salty. Put on your thick skin suit, because if you're (and I mean the collective "you", not any one individual) not catching or landing fish, his form of pep talk is to give hell.


The fishing. Happy to hear the plan was to go South for YT, YFT, and Dodos. Good news when last trip was north for BFT and the numbers were horrible, especially when the numbers South were so strong (and my freezer is full). Got some OK sardines (lot's of bad mixed with some good ones) and got to the fishing grounds early, around 3:00 am. Rather than look for a night bite, Capt. decided to shut it down and wait for grey light. Up early at 5. Started out for our first patty around 6:00, which was only 20 minuted away. It had a transponder on it from the day before. Threw my first dine and got bit. It ripped line off my reel and went straight into the patty. Pulled, tugged, and reeled for 20 minutes and the thing wouldn't budge. Finally broke off. Apparently, while I was struggling, so was the entire boat. Of all the hook ups, only 8 or so landed. Bad start for Capt. Taft and we heard about it. Left that patty and found another a little later. Better luck, more landed. Better quality. The day went like this until 5 pm or so. Each patty got progressively better...I think as a whole, the group settled in a bit and stopped fishing frantically. My highlight was being the single hook up on a patty, turned out to be a decent 12 lb dodo that jumped 6 or 7 times. Fun hollering at that beautiful fish as it breached the surface. All I could see was the hook flying out of it's mouth, but it didn't. Pretty cool. In the end had 10 YT ranging from a few pounds to 16 or 17. All 5 of my keepers were over 15 lbs. 1 Dodo and 1, 25 lb. YFT. Went 12/18 or so. Beautiful day, good fishing, fun crew. Inspired me to write this.

Overall, I'd fish the Excalibur again. Not perfect, but better than many I've fished. One thing to note, lot's of newbies on this trip. Two families with kids. Not good or bad, just an observation. AND, finally figured out how to attach my iPhone to the bunk above me, resolving the issue of having to hold the thing for 2 hours. Definitely and good day. Tight lines and can't wait for the next trip....
 

Dbado1

Member
  • Jul 17, 2020
    349
    445
    63
    Arizona
    Name
    Robert D Bado
    Boat Name
    Toyota tundra
    Nice! Thank you for the report.
    I don't get the whole, " let's go fish for non biting BF" while the rest of the fleet is killing the the other species. Personally, I would much rather go for the variety than fish for BF. Especially if the trophy BF are not around. Anyway, good on you guys!
     
    Upvote 0

    scbassmaster

    twin22s
    Sep 8, 2006
    611
    1,123
    36
    san clemente
    Name
    Brian
    Boat Name
    1982 Glastron SeaFury216 “Elizabeth”
    I fished with Chuck, and can second the salty attitude, ribbed us the whole trip about getting beat by the fish but then said we should be proud of our catch on the way home, interesting dude. Not quite as bad as steve though.
     
    Upvote 0

    WmWiley

    Newbie
    May 21, 2021
    22
    113
    60
    Point Loma
    Name
    Steven Vogt
    Boat Name
    CynSea
    I fished with Chuck, and can second the salty attitude, ribbed us the whole trip about getting beat by the fish but then said we should be proud of our catch on the way home, interesting dude. Not quite as bad as steve though.
    Some on this trip. Different script just before tip time...
     
    Upvote 0

    Tar Pit

    I Should Upgrade My Account
  • Mar 7, 2006
    1,353
    1,004
    Reno NV
    Name
    Friend of Bucko Shaw
    Boat Name
    None.
    Hook size? What line test? Anybody throwing jigs?

    Thanks for the report.
     
    Upvote 0

    WmWiley

    Newbie
    May 21, 2021
    22
    113
    60
    Point Loma
    Name
    Steven Vogt
    Boat Name
    CynSea
    All my fish were caught flylining. I didn't see anyone throwing irons for very long. A few may have been caught on irons, but I didn't see any. The set ups I used were sx raptor 50/30lb #2 ringed circle hook, sx raptor 50/40lb #2 ringed circle hook, jx raptor 65/30lb. #2 ringed circle hook. They were hitting the 40lb flouro as much as the 30. Didn't seem to make a difference. The bait was pretty large 5-7 inches or so, and could handle larger hooks. Bait selection was key. Lot's of bloody, slow swimmers mixed in with nice shiny ones. I saw a lot of guys baiting up some pretty nasty dines.
     
    Upvote 0

    Tunahead

    Long Time Tuna Abused Member
  • Aug 11, 2006
    18,093
    11,042
    Costa Mesa
    Name
    Ron
    Boat Name
    several
    Cool report gives and takes. Glad ya got some nice yellows and a dorado.
    Ol' salty Chuck been around as long as me I think by now. LOL
    What NO PICS? The gang wants pics here!!

    BEEF.jpg
     
    • Like
    Reactions: WmWiley
    Upvote 0

    bdubs73

    Member
    Feb 7, 2008
    757
    1,251
    San Diego
    Name
    Brian
    Boat Name
    none
    I
    Long time reader, first time poster. Go easy. I'll be brief.

    First time on the Excalibur. Pros and Cons:

    Pros:
    1. The crew. Ryan and Alex on deck, Jr. was training (his first day and he was very good. Helpful, a small guy, so agile on deck. Always asking if he can tie a knot or undo a tangle.) All three were good at helping and seeing problems before they happen. Omar was the chef and made some decent meals.
    2. Older wooden boat, so smooth ride and good sleep. Creaked like a muthah, though.
    3. Huge bunks. Mostly, if not all, doubles. Very wide, very long. Several staterooms as well. I had a stateroom and appreciated the extra large bunk size.
    4. Good fishing platform...lot's of room to negotiate during open bites.
    5. Capt. Chuck Taft. Salty and put us on fish.


    Cons:
    1. Old wooden boat, so you're not going anywhere fast.
    2. No place sit on deck, which is pretty common, so bring a chair if you want to sit.
    3. Lot's of freeboard at the bow, but spacious enough to comfortably throw irons, not so good for flylining.
    4. Our stateroom blew hot air out of the a/c registers. That sucked.
    5. $30 fuel surcharge, but that's expected.
    6. Capt. Chuck Taft...salty...real salty. Put on your thick skin suit, because if you're (and I mean the collective "you", not any one individual) not catching or landing fish, his form of pep talk is to give hell.


    The fishing. Happy to hear the plan was to go South for YT, YFT, and Dodos. Good news when last trip was north for BFT and the numbers were horrible, especially when the numbers South were so strong (and my freezer is full). Got some OK sardines (lot's of bad mixed with some good ones) and got to the fishing grounds early, around 3:00 am. Rather than look for a night bite, Capt. decided to shut it down and wait for grey light. Up early at 5. Started out for our first patty around 6:00, which was only 20 minuted away. It had a transponder on it from the day before. Threw my first dine and got bit. It ripped line off my reel and went straight into the patty. Pulled, tugged, and reeled for 20 minutes and the thing wouldn't budge. Finally broke off. Apparently, while I was struggling, so was the entire boat. Of all the hook ups, only 8 or so landed. Bad start for Capt. Taft and we heard about it. Left that patty and found another a little later. Better luck, more landed. Better quality. The day went like this until 5 pm or so. Each patty got progressively better...I think as a whole, the group settled in a bit and stopped fishing frantically. My highlight was being the single hook up on a patty, turned out to be a decent 12 lb dodo that jumped 6 or 7 times. Fun hollering at that beautiful fish as it breached the surface. All I could see was the hook flying out of it's mouth, but it didn't. Pretty cool. In the end had 10 YT ranging from a few pounds to 16 or 17. All 5 of my keepers were over 15 lbs. 1 Dodo and 1, 25 lb. YFT. Went 12/18 or so. Beautiful day, good fishing, fun crew. Inspired me to write this.

    Overall, I'd fish the Excalibur again. Not perfect, but better than many I've fished. One thing to note, lot's of newbies on this trip. Two families with kids. Not good or bad, just an observation. AND, finally figured out how to attach my iPhone to the bunk above me, resolving the issue of having to hold the thing for 2 hours. Definitely and good day. Tight lines and can't wait for the next trip....
    'd be grateful to hear about your method of attaching your phone to the bunk, that drives me nuts having to hold it! Congrats on the trip, love the acrobatic Dorado. How was the captain and crew with the kids?
     
    Upvote 0

    WmWiley

    Newbie
    May 21, 2021
    22
    113
    60
    Point Loma
    Name
    Steven Vogt
    Boat Name
    CynSea
    Cool report gives and takes. Glad ya got some nice yellows and a dorado.
    Ol' salty Chuck been around as long as me I think by now. LOL
    What NO PICS? The gang wants pics here!!

    View attachment 1405731
    I took one photo. I was #14, if you can make out the fish tags. I find it tough to take pics during a bite. But, others can do it, so I’ll give it a try next time.

    F0FFF6C7-31D5-47C6-88C7-D44F01CF530C.jpeg
     
    • Like
    Reactions: Tunahead
    Upvote 0