I have several assorted Saltiga star drags, 1 Andros and 1 BX2-400. I played with the Saltiga lever drag reels in a tackle shop and wasn't very impressed, and even my wife calls me a Saltiga snob. I just got my second Makaira and am very anxious to break it in.
Of the 2 reels listed that I have fished:
Andros will cast better and is a very light, comfortable reel to fish; the first fish I caught on mine was a 30# paddy YT
on the way to Cedros last year. I deliberately fished it alternating with a Saltiga 20 star drag and I was casting live baits further with the Andros every time, but the drag cam on my Andros only produces drag within the last 5 clicks before strike. I don't like that.
Accurate has the better drag; the first fish I caught on the BX2-400 was a 45# Cedros Yt
(the day after I caught the other YT
on the Andros)
Both of these reels shifted gears with no problem mid fight, and I had no problems with either. I cannot comment on the Saltiga 2 because I have not fished it yet.
Reels you didn't list but are comparable: